National Academies:

New Heroes

John Clauser

When I photographed John Clauser in 2024, his garage workshop was crowded with electronics, tangled wires, and the remains of experiments. There were old computers and an even older drill press. Nautical charts shared space with scientific papers, and the name of his boat, Bodacious+, was stitched on his black polo shirt. I had come to meet a man who helped turn one of Einstein’s deepest objections to quantum mechanics into an experiment.

The question concerned quantum entanglement. Two particles can share a quantum state even after they separate. Measure them independently, then compare the results, and patterns appear that defy our ordinary understanding of separate objects.

Imagine sending two photons in opposite directions and measuring their polarization, a property related to the orientation of light’s electric field. Each result, considered alone, can appear random. But across many pairs, the results are correlated in ways quantum mechanics predicts with extraordinary precision. How could particles so far apart belong to such a closely coordinated whole?

Einstein objected to what he called “spooky action at a distance.” He suspected that quantum mechanics was incomplete. Perhaps the particles carried hidden information that would explain their behavior without any mysterious influence passing between them.

In 1964, John Bell showed that this disagreement could be tested. Under the assumptions of a local hidden-variable theory, correlations between measurements must stay within certain mathematical limits. Quantum mechanics predicted that entangled particles could exceed those limits.

John wanted to find out. Working with Stuart Freedman at Berkeley, he built an apparatus that sent pairs of photons through polarizing filters toward separate detectors. They changed the filters’ angles and counted how often both photons were detected. A question about the structure of reality came down to an experiment someone had to build, align, and run.

Their 1972 results exceeded the limit set by a Bell inequality and agreed with quantum mechanics. John had hoped to find a flaw in the theory. Instead, his experiment supported the very prediction he had doubted. There were loopholes for later experiments to address, but he and Freedman had shown that this unsettling feature of nature could be brought into the laboratory.

Entanglement does not allow messages to travel faster than light. What it challenges is the idea that the correlations arise entirely from information the particles carry separately, unaffected by distant measurement choices. The implications helped open the field of quantum information science. In 2022, John shared the Nobel Prize in Physics with Alain Aspect and Anton Zeilinger.

Sitting with him among the wires and old equipment, I kept thinking about the distance between understanding an equation and understanding what it says about the world. Here was someone who had built a way to ask nature a question and accepted an answer he had not expected.

I couldn’t help asking if he thought we had a good idea of how the universe really works.

He thought for a second, then looked right at me.

“Our mathematical models are very good,” he said. “But math isn’t the universe.”


Discover more from National Academies:

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.